mc.roleplayhub.com

players online

How Much Animals Roll

Kayla1511

Level 7
What's your Minecraft Username?: sinarei
What's the title of your suggestion?: How Much Animals Roll

What's your suggestion?:
So via the SRP rules all animals have to roll seventy five (75). For me that makes no sense because then that means that a small kitten would roll the same as a massive dog. I have a dog character, his name is Max 'Maxxy' and he weighs 197 lbs. He's four feet long and three feet tall. The other day a four feet and six inches tall guy attacked Max, that guy was eighteen years old, and rolled 150, while I had to roll 75. The man weighed 90 lbs, which was indicated in his description. The man rolled 94 out of 150 and I rolled a 75 out of 75. So I was wondering what was y'all's intake on this rule. I vote that in the character authorisations dog characters should be allowed to make a proper application asking to roll atleast on 100, not 150.

How will this benefit the server and community?:
Well I think that the RP should stay somewhat realistic. Even full grown men are afraid of massive dogs so why shouldn't a eighteen year old?
 

Yonio

Level 333
YonioTheNacho
YonioTheNacho
Omega+
I said this in a recent suggestion; Animals with a higher body proportion and strength than humans should not go for roll-based combat. If, for whatever reason, your combatant doesn't wanna agree to P2L you because they want to use rolls instead, then you probably shouldn't CombatRP with them, simply because they're more focused on winning rather than actual realism

Moreover, unless SRP introduces a way to automatically define your combat roll depending on your role, I don't see this suggestion getting accepted, simply because people already find rolling hard enough as is
 

Kayla1511

Level 7
Thread starter
I said this in a recent suggestion; Animals with a higher body proportion and strength than humans should not go for roll-based combat. If, for whatever reason, your combatant doesn't wanna agree to P2L you because they want to use rolls instead, then you probably shouldn't CombatRP with them, simply because they're more focused on winning rather than actual realism

Moreover, unless SRP introduces a way to automatically define your combat roll depending on your role, I don't see this suggestion getting accepted, simply because people already find rolling hard enough as is
I understand that, but many people don't actually want to p2l since they ARE more interested in actually winning then realistically fighting.
 

DarkEclipic

Level 209
Community Team
Lore Team
DarkEclipic
DarkEclipic
Omega+
-1
Suggestions relating about animals being able to roll higher have been denied over and over again and they will not be getting a boost. Here is the latest suggestion that was denied.


In there, in my post on it, you can find even more denied animal whitest posts. In short it is P2W and that is not allowed on the server and breaks Minecraft's tos or EULA or something like that.

If you want roleplay on animals, just P2L. Don't like P2L? Then stick with the set rolling amount

Please note I never reply back to suggestions once I post them, if you do wish to fight your opinion, please DM me on here or discord. Thank you
 

Mo!

Level 48
Moderator
sunsetskies_
sunsetskies_
Omega+
-1
Animals have set rolls because they are weaker than humans, sure, they get training but why are they being trained in SchoolRP when they cannot partake in crimerp/gangrp?

Your animal shouldn't be fighting, if you wish to fight, you can use your 'human' character.
 

Yonio

Level 333
YonioTheNacho
YonioTheNacho
Omega+
I understand that, but many people don't actually want to p2l since they ARE more interested in actually winning then realistically fighting.
If this is the case, then you should probably not engage in CombatRP (or roleplay altogether) with them. Roleplay is all about realism. Remember that, as an animal character, it's not always about rolling; As a dangerous animal (in your case, it seems like a dog that big would be considered a dangerous animal), you have the option to inflict FearRP onto someone (the actual "forced" fear would depend on many factors, I suggest reaching out to staff to confirm this). If they fail to FearRP or react realistically just so they can get a quick knock-out, you may contact staff, as they're probably either failing to FearRP, baiting permissions on your dog character, and/or just FailRPing
 

Kayla1511

Level 7
Thread starter
-1
Animals have set rolls because they are weaker than humans, sure, they get training but why are they being trained in SchoolRP when they cannot partake in crimerp/gangrp?

Your animal shouldn't be fighting, if you wish to fight, you can use your 'human' character.
I understand that my animal shouldn't be fighting, but if my dog character is being attacked, he wouldn't run away. As bears, birds, and practically every single animal, when provoked would attack.
 

Kayla1511

Level 7
Thread starter
If this is the case, then you should probably not engage in CombatRP (or roleplay altogether) with them. Roleplay is all about realism. Remember that, as an animal character, it's not always about rolling; As a dangerous animal (in your case, it seems like a dog that big would be considered a dangerous animal), you have the option to inflict FearRP onto someone (the actual "forced" fear would depend on many factors, I suggest reaching out to staff to confirm this). If they fail to FearRP or react realistically just so they can get a quick knock-out, you may contact staff, as they're probably either failing to FearRP, baiting permissions on your dog character, and/or just FailRPing
Yes that I also understand, and I will contact staff about FearRP rules.
 

KimiNoUso

Level 371
Owner
HS Sports Lead
KimiNoUso
KimiNoUso
Omega+
Denied
Thank you for your suggestion! After discussing this with the team we have decided to decline it.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top